Condo or co-op when you live abroad

For a buyer who lives outside the United States, a condo is almost always the workable choice. A condo is real property: you get a deed, you can rent it out within the building’s rules, and the board cannot simply refuse you. A co-op sells shares in a corporation, and its board can reject a buyer without giving a reason. Many co-op boards will not approve a buyer whose income and assets are abroad.

Not tax or legal advice. This page explains public rules in plain words. Rules change, and your own facts matter. Confirm with a licensed professional before you act.

The difference in one table

CondoCo-op
What you ownThe unit itself, by deedShares in a corporation, plus a lease on the unit
Board powerUsually a right of first refusal: the board may buy the unit on the same terms, and rarely doesApproval required; the board can say no
Buying through a company or trustCommonly acceptedOften not allowed
Renting it outAllowed, within building rulesOften limited to a few years, or not allowed
Buying from abroadRoutineHard: boards want US income, US assets and an interview
Mortgage recording tax with a loanYesReported as not charged, because a co-op loan is not a mortgage on real property
Mansion tax and transfer taxesYesYes
PriceHigher for a similar apartmentLower

Why co-op boards say no to buyers abroad

A co-op is a shared financial structure. If one owner stops paying, the others cover it. Boards therefore want income and assets they can verify and reach, and those are easier to check in the United States. Many also want owners who live in the building. A second home held from abroad, or a rental, runs against both.

Two in-between types

  • Condop. Legally a co-op, run with condo-style rules. Some accept foreign buyers. Ask for the rules in writing.
  • Sponsor unit in a co-op. Sold by the original developer or owner, sometimes without board approval. The building’s other rules, such as limits on renting, still apply.

What to check in a condo before you sign

  1. The rental rules: minimum lease length, fees, and any cap on rented units.
  2. Whether the building accepts purchases by a company.
  3. The application: what documents it asks for from someone without a US credit history.
  4. Common charges, property tax, and any assessment that is planned.
  5. The unit’s city market value, for the surcharge.

Buying from abroad: the whole process