Own name, LLC or foreign company: what each one changes

How you hold title changes three things: your privacy, your exposure if someone sues over the property, and what happens with US estate tax if you die while owning it. It does not change the price, the transfer taxes or the withholding at sale. This page describes each option. It does not tell you which to choose. That is a decision for you and a tax adviser who knows both countries.

Not tax or legal advice. This page explains public rules in plain words. Rules change, and your own facts matter. Confirm with a licensed professional before you act.

The estate-tax fact most buyers abroad do not know

When a person who is neither a US citizen nor living in the US dies owning US property, the US estate tax looks at their US-situated assets. The IRS lists US real estate among them. An estate tax return (Form 706-NA) is required when those assets are worth more than $60,000. For US citizens and residents the threshold is in the millions.

A $1.5 million condo in your own name is therefore far above the line. Some tax treaties change the result. Whether yours does is a question for an adviser.

The options

In your own nameUS LLC that you own directlyCompany formed in your home country that owns the condo, directly or through a US LLC
Your name on the public deedYesThe LLC’s nameThe company’s name
Liability shieldNoYesYes
US estate taxThe condo counts as a US assetLaw firms write that a single-member LLC owned directly by a person abroad does not by itself change thisOften used for this reason; it brings other tax costs and yearly filings
Paperwork each yearLowestUS filings for the LLCHighest: two sets of accounts and returns
Condo applicationSimplestCommonly accepted; the building asks who is behind itAccepted by many condos; more documents
LoanEasiestFewer lendersFewest lenders
Surcharge on non-primary homesOwner or family living there countsThe city looks at the person holding a majority interestSame test, more documents
Withholding at sale15% if you are a foreign personDepends on how the LLC is taxedDepends on the structure

Things people get wrong

  • “An LLC removes the estate tax.” Not by itself, according to the law firms we read.
  • “I can move it into a company later for free.” A transfer after closing can trigger taxes and fees of its own. Decide before you sign the contract.
  • “The company hides me.” The building, the bank and the title company will all ask who the real owner is.

Questions to bring to an adviser

  1. Does my country have an estate-tax treaty with the United States, and what does it do for real estate?
  2. What does each structure cost me per year, in both countries?
  3. How is rent taxed under each?
  4. What happens at sale under each?
  5. What happens if I move to the US later?