Renting your condo out: does a tenant remove the surcharge?

Yes, if the tenant really lives there. The NYC Department of Finance lists “a tenant or subtenant” among the people whose primary residence takes a home out of the non-primary-residence surcharge. You have to prove it with the tenant’s own documents and the lease. A tenant who keeps the unit as a second home does not count.

Not tax or legal advice. This page explains public rules in plain words. Rules change, and your own facts matter. Confirm with a licensed professional before you act.

What the city asks for

For a rented unit, DOF asks for two sets of papers.

About the tenant (the person who lives there):

  • their most recent federal or state tax return, or a driver’s licence or other DMV-issued ID showing the address;
  • if they have neither, a voter ID card plus other proof of primary residence.

About the tenancy, one of:

  • the current lease plus one more rental document (a utility bill, proof of rent payment or renter’s insurance); or
  • DOF’s Tenant or Subtenant Affidavit plus two more rental documents.

Source: NYC Department of Finance, read November 16, 2026.

What this means for an investor abroad

  • A long-term rental is treated differently from an empty unit. A condo rented to someone who lives in it all year is outside the surcharge. The same condo kept empty for your visits is inside it, if the city values it at $1,000,000 or more.
  • Your tenant’s paperwork becomes your paperwork. Put it in the lease: the tenant agrees to give the documents the city asks for. Ask your attorney for the wording.
  • Gaps between tenants matter. The DOF page does not explain how a vacancy during the year is treated. Ask before you rely on a partial year.
  • Check the building. Some condos limit how short a lease can be.

What we could not confirm

Several law firms write that the lease must be for at least a year. The DOF page we read does not state a minimum. Until we have read it in the law or in DOF’s rules, treat the minimum lease length as an open question.